I had mentioned a month or so back that I was looking into the Columbus College of Art & Design (CCAD) as an option to transfer to from Michigan. I was unhappy but more than anything just unsure about the quality of the education I was receiving in industrial design. Chiefly I was concerned about the perceived lack of product design experience and basic design skills at Michigan because of the openness of the A&D curriculum (after our core courses, there are a whole selection of advanced studios we can take, some offered regularly, some not).
This was until I got a closer look at the advanced studios pertaining to I.D. and had talked closer with professors. But just to be safe, and make sure I was making the correct choice, I visited CCAD, which was my top alternative to Michigan. They have a pretty well known ID group, but after visiting today, I have no clue why.
I was unimpressed with the facilities for industrial design for one, paltry and small at best. Also, after coming from a school like Michigan, where things can be hectic and unorganized, this school was a bit off (it was a college day type event, I was impressed by how poor everything was set up, tours before information sessions, not showing you any work spaces in the tour only showing you what some students have done). I was able to talk with the head of the industrial design department there for a bit and came away underwhelmed about the school. It seemed that while there was definitely a course structure set up for you, it seemed very rigid, with little opportunity to try different techniques. Also, being a small private art school, they had no possibility of minoring in anything other than art history or fine arts. I'm interested in a psych minor focusing on how people interact with objects to complement my B.F.A in industrial design I'm getting and my 3 year concentration on mechanical engineering. That's out the window at CCAD.
Oh and the kicker, here I am worried that Michigan won't be able to teach me the technical skills of design and model making and CCAD doesn't even have a freaking laser cutter, M has two. Or vacuum former, M has 2, one large one smaller. Or 3-d mill, M has 2 I think. Or rapid prototyping, M has one. I was amazed. How can you make really intricate designs look really really professionally cutting all by hand? Those CCAD ID grads must be wizards with a good ol' exacto knife!
Plus I'd lose a year in transferring schools, so it would take me 8 years to graduate. Nope, now way at all.
So yeah, I'm staying put at Michigan. If looking at other schools has shown me anything about M A&D, it's that we have some pretty cool technologies available to us and to be thankful for all the extra interesting opportunities that Michigan gives you.
Oh and I love Michigan football so that's a big plus. Columbus is kinda a sucky city anyway. Ann Arbor rules.
Thanks for reading! Go Blue!
Monday, December 8, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
Word.
OH-IO!
xoxo,
Guess Who
I am a Senior at CCAD, and I feel that you should get your facts correct before you comment about our school so negatively.
First, we have a rapid prototyping machine as well as a vacuum former.
Second, we are moving to new facilities which are in excess of 50,000 square feet.
Also, our program is accredited by NASD and ACAD as well as IDSA. These organizations require programs to uphold academic excellence standards.
It is unfortunate that you feel we did not accommodate you well during your visit. But, I feel that our program is one of the top in the country.
And I believe the success of our graduates speaks for itself.
I agree that A&D can be very frustrating but I think that success around here derives from going above and beyond what's expected and finding the resources for yourself. I see a lot of shit flowing through the school, but I think we're the ones who have to change that.
ummm a&d has 3 prototyping machines...4 if you count the 3D scanner. i'd recommend 3D modeling and animation, one of shawn or jans classes, and some IDSA meetings. they do a ton of demos, have a lot of visiting artists, and are really ontop of everything. just dive in Pete!!
Yeah, I'm involved with IDSA and I'm taking classes with both Shawn and Jan's next semester. I was feeling lost earlier in the year, just frustrated with cfc b.s.
I'm really looking forward to Designer Bootcamp with Shawn!
Post a Comment